Thoughts on Winchester Station Approach

fight In the red corner, Hopkins Architects with their urban design prowess. In the blue corner, Design Engine, the local team, modern architecture at it's best. Ding ding, let the battle commence.... What is clear both propositions are towering giants, the effort has been huge, but someone has to be knocked out, it's going to hurt. Perhaps it was better not to have fought at all? May the best titan win.